Anonymous writes:
Michelina's Italian Restaurant on West Henrietta Road. A well-kept secret. Small, with not a lot of tables, but the food is outstanding. We've been going there for at least the past 5 years, because of the consistently high quality of their food.

We highly recommend their specials — always top-notch. They take reservations for small parties, even on Fridays, when many other Henrietta-area restaurants do not.

Editor writes:
We headed out here on a Friday night without reservations. The small place was crowded but we were seated immediately. It used to be a Mexican restaurant and it seemed very familiar inside. The back room is very comfortable with booths against the walls and and a row of tables down the middle. The service was friendly and fast. We were hungary so we got right down to business. I ordered Stuffed Pork Braciole and my wife ordered Chicken Piccata. They serve the salad "family style" and there is no choice of dressing. They put a big bowl on the table and you help yourself. It came with a simple oil and vinegar dressing and there was enough salad for me to have two big helpings. The entrees were great and the Italian instrumental accordion music on the sound system was just right.